Increase text size: A A A

Type in the condition you need,
or visit Advanced Search

Print this page

Email this to a friend

Comment on this page

Save to my Health Library

Johns Hopkins Health Alert

Dr. Mostwin Answers Readers’ Questions

In this Health Alert, Dr. Jacek L. Mostwin, a urological surgeon at Johns Hopkins, answers readers’ questions about prostate cancer treatment. The questions come from a recent issue of the Johns Hopkins Prostate Bulletin.

  • Prostate Cancer Question 1: RADIATION OR SURGERY

Q. Well, I am now officially a member of the “prostate cancer club.” My doctor called me yesterday with my biopsy results: Gleason 7 and PSA of 6.8 ng/ml. I am 63 years old and will do something soon to get rid of the prostate cancer. I have been divorced for two years now and still have an active dating life, which is one of the reasons I have been considering radiation therapy as my treatment. Losing my erection to prostate surgery would be too great a sacrifice for me right now. My best friend, who had a radical prostatectomy three years ago (and now successfully uses Viagra), tells me that with radiation you can never be sure all the cancer has been killed off, so I should go with the surgery? Annapolis, MD

A. With respect to surgery, it is fair to say that if you can be cured, you will be cured. By that I mean, if the cancer has not yet spread out of the prostate, and the gland is removed before that possibility ever develops, you will never have the disease again. It is not at all clear that radiation therapy can offer that outcome. With respect to potency, the nerve bundles are located within millimeters of the prostatic capsule. During surgery, one can separate them and still remove all cancer. It is more difficult for radiation to preserve these nerves while still applying the high energy to the prostatic tissues only millimeters away.

  • Prostate Cancer Question 2: POSITIVE MARGIN REMAINING

Q. I love the Prostate Bulletin! Thank you! On July 2, 2007, I had my prostate removed by a surgeon using a Da Vinci robot. Unfortunately, the doctor left behind some of my prostate -- a positive margin on the left side. The pathology report showed: Adenocarcinoma (conventional, not otherwise specified), a Gleason of 3+4, with a stage of nT2c, and 20% of prostatic tissue involved. My biopsies had shown no prostate cancer on that left side. In 2004, I had a PSA of 1.72 ng/ml; in 2006, it was 1.92. Just prior to the surgery, my PSA was up to 2.0. I am thinking of coming to Johns Hopkins to have that remaining positive margin tissue removed by means of regular open surgery. Do you know of any similar cases (i.e., having an open surgery done to correct mistakes made by a robotic surgery)? Via E-mail

A. Whether the prostate surgery is performed by an open, robotic, or laparoscopic technique, the interior scarring will be the same. In general, it’s very rare to operate on the prostate a second time to remove additional prostatic tissue. We have done it once after an obviously incomplete prostatectomy was performed on a very young patient, but the operation was profoundly difficult, as scarring from the first operation made the field almost impossible to work in. If only a minute margin is suspected, it would be inadvisable to re-operate. It’s unlikely that the tissue would ever be found, and a lot of damage could be done.

Your situation is really too complicated to address here, but one can make a few general comments. If the positive margin is due to a small amount of tissue and the PSA falls to an undetectable level after prostate surgery, there may be no need to treat right now, although a practitioner might advise supplemental radiation therapy even before waiting to see if the PSA goes up. If, on the other hand, a large piece of the prostate was left behind, there were grossly positive margins, and the PSA was still elevated after surgery, then one could make a case for additional radiation therapy right away.

Posted in Prostate Disorders on March 27, 2008

Notify Me

Would you like us to inform you when we post new Prostate Disorders Health Alerts?

Your email address:

Comments

Post a Comment

Users and editors may post comments here at their own discretion. The views expressed do not constitute medical advice and do not represent the position of Johns Hopkins Medicine or University Health Publishing, which has no responsibility for its content.




Post a Comment


New to the Johns Hopkins Health Alerts?
Signup

User Name:


This appears next to your comment.


Email Address:

(this will not be posted)
This will be your login ID.

Password:

Confirm Password:


Receive Health Alerts?

Notify me when new comments are posted?

Comment (offensive materials and/or spam will be removed, no HTML allowed)

Already a subscriber?
Login

Email:

Password:


Forgot your password?

Registered Users Log-in:

Email:

Password:

Remember me
Forgot Password?

Become a Registered User!
It's fast and FREE!
The Benefits of Being A Registered User

Health Topic Pages

Arthritis +Add
Back Pain & Osteoporosis +Add
Caregivers | Caregiving
Colon Cancer +Add
Complementary Medicine
Depression & Anxiety +Add
Diabetes +Add
Digestive Health +Add
Exercise and Fitness
Healthy Living +Add
Heart Health +Add
Hypertension & Stroke +Add
Lung Disorders +Add
Memory +Add
Men's Health
Nutrition +Add
Prescription Drugs +Add
Prostate Disorders +Add
Sexual Health
Vision +Add
Weight Control +Add
Women's Health
Health Alert Special Report

Johns Hopkins' Bestsellers

Prostate Disorders

Our Featured Title:

Johns Hopkins White Papers 2008


Related Titles:

The Johns Hopkins Prostate Bulletin Cover

  • The Johns Hopkins Prostate Bulletin
    The Johns Hopkins Prostate Bulletin
    is a quarterly publication that presents the latest treatment information available on prostate cancer, enlarged prostate (BPH), and prostatitis to help you take charge of your medical care for prostate disease. Each issue is like having an in-depth consultation with a leading specialist. PLUS, subscribe now and get a special discount PLUS 5 FREE Special Reports as INSTANT PDF DOWNLOADS:
    • Special Report #1: BPH (Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia)
    • Special Report #2: Diet and Prostate Health
    • Special Report #3: Treating Overactive Bladder
    • Special Report #4: Chronic Prostatitis: New Research, Renewed Hope
    • Special Report #5: The Radical Prostatectomy

    Click here to read more or order The Johns Hopkins Prostate Bulletin.


  • THE JOHNS HOPKINS PROSTATE LIBRARY

    A series of cutting-edge publications designed to address your specific prostate questions.

    • ChoosingThe Right Treatment For Your Prostate Cancer
      You have hundreds of questions about your prostate cancer. America's #1 Urology Center's specialists have the answers.ChoosingThe Right Treatment For Your Prostate Cancer is a detailed, up-to-the-minute treatment guide so you can know all your options before making any irrevocable decisions about your prostate cancer treatment.Read more...

    • JohnsHopkins Prostate Bulletin: Prostate Cancer Review 2007
      Where we've been, where we are, and where we're going in the world of prostate cancer diagnosis and effective prostate cancer treatment.Readmore....

    • JohnsHopkins Prostate Bulletin: The Radical Prostatectomy, by Dr. Patrick Walsh; Rare and Unusual Cancers of theProstate
      On the 25th anniversary of his first performing a radical prosatectomy, Dr. Patrick Walsh brings you up to date on what you need to know about this procedure, and how to choose the best surgeon for YOU. Plus, the prostate can be affected by other forms of cancer than prostate cancer. Could your doctor be missing something?Readmore...

    • JohnsHopkins Prostate Bulletin: The Future of Prostate Surgical Technology; The AUA PSA Testing Debate
      The latest information on emerging technologies to treat prostate cancer, including robotic radical prostatectomy, and HIFU. Plus, learn more about the ongoing debate concerning the benefits versus drawbacks of PSA Testing for older men, straight from the American Urological Association Conference Debate.Readmore...


    ALL NEW!Number One of America's Best Hospitals 2007: Johns Hopkins

    Johns Hopkins has been ranked #1 again in the Honor Roll of America's Best Hospitals by
    U.S. News and World Report for the 17th consecutive year.


    Please visit here for more information about Johns Hopkins Patient Services


    Medical Disclaimer: The information on this page is not intended to substitute for the advice of a physician.


    Charter Subscription to The Johns Hopkins Prostate Bulletin

    PLUS 5 FREE Special Reports, available right now as INSTANT PDF DOWNLOADS

    The Johns Hopkins Prostate Bulletin

    The Johns Hopkins Prostate Bulletin brings you up-to-the-minute information about the latest advances in prostate medicine, from the very experts at the forefront of life-saving discoveries in this vital field. From prostate cancer, and prostate surgery and common side effects such as erectile dysfunction and incontinence, to prostatitis, to Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia (BPH) to Prostate Cancer, The Johns Hopkins Prostate Bulletin provides the most cutting–edge information for men (and their loved ones!) facing these health challenges. It's like having an in-depth consultation from a specialist from America's #1 medical center.

    ADDED BONUS: FREE SPECIAL REPORTS!

    Click here for details:

    Prostate Cancer Information Yes! Enter my charter subscription to The Johns Hopkins PROSTATE BULLETIN on a risk-FREE basis at the charter subscription rate of $149 for one year (4 quarterly issues)—that's a discount of $46 off the regular subscription price thanks to this web-only offer.

    TO ACCEPT THIS RISK-FREE OFFER,
    simply fill out the form and click "Submit my order."

    First Name

    Last Name

    Address

    Address2

    City

    State

    Zip

    Email Address (required)


    CANADIAN ORDERS, click here
    INTERNATIONAL ORDERS, click here


    Please send me my FREE Johns Hopkins Prostate Health Alerts via email.


    What you will get with your subscription to The Johns Hopkins Prostate Bulletin.
    In every issue of your Johns Hopkins Prostate Bulletin, you'll receive:

  • Quarterly briefings on the latest medical developments
  • Late breaking news of innovative new treatments and essential health study results
  • Expert evaluations and comparisons of new medications, surgical techniques, and diagnostic procedures
  • Authoritative medical guidance from leading experts around the world
  • At least one in-depth Special Report or update on the most important breakthroughs in prostate cancer, BPH, ED, LUTS, or prostatitis.
  • Answers to your most pressing questions about your prostate disorders in the Grand Rounds section
  • ALL delivered direct to you via Priority Mail!

    As soon as you place your order, you will also receive your five FREE Prostate Disorders Special Reports as INSTANT PDF DOWNLOADS, so you can start using the information you learn right away in your quest for answers about your medical condition and how best to treat it.
    * Prostate Bulletin Special Report #1: BPH (Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia)
    * Prostate Bulletin Special Report #2: Diet and Prostate Health
    * Prostate Bulletin Special Report #3: Treating Overactive Bladder
    * Prostate Bulletin Special Report #4: Chronic Prostatitis: New Research, Renewed Hope
    * Prostate Bulletin Special Report #5: The Radical Prostatectomy

    Your risk-FREE subscription and 100% money-back guarantee. The Johns Hopkins Prostate Bulletin is yours to review risk-FREE. If you are not completely satisfied, simply return the Bulletin and receive a refund with no questions asked. Keep the five Prostate Disorders Special Reports just for reviewing the Bulletin.

    Only by private subscription. Don't bother looking for The Johns Hopkins Prostate Bulletin on the newsstand. It is available only by private subscription, delivered directly to you quarterly via Priority Mail.

    Why Johns Hopkins?


  • © 2008 Medletter Associates, LLC. All rights reserved.
    Contact Us
    customerservice@johnshopkinshealthalerts.com